Insights

Clan War Strategy Report: Sitting Ducks

OVERVIEW

Sitting Ducks has a concerning 40% win rate over the last 20 wars, indicating strategic or execution issues. While 20 players are reliably active, a significant number of "moderate" players and one "unreliable" player contribute to inconsistent war performance through missed attacks. This inconsistency directly impacts the clan's ability to win.

MVPs

TopShelf (2.83 avg), C-Dub (2.76 avg), and ++Shifty++ (2.76 avg) are consistently carrying the clan in terms of star performance. Their high average stars are crucial and demonstrate strong offensive capability, forming the backbone of any successful war effort.

BENCH LIST

Rico ll (67% atk) is a clear bench candidate due to very low reliability and multiple recent missed attacks. We should also bench ⚜Who Dat⚜, The Godfather, nirvana, PRO⚡️EMPEROR, LilWeezyAna, and BigDaddyDyl, who, despite varying star averages, have all missed attacks in recent wars, particularly on February 15th. Their recent inactivity directly undermines war planning and commitment.

FREELOADERS

A substantial 17 members are chronically opted out, with 15 consistently out for all 5 recent checks. Members like DOUBLE DOUBLE (0% atk), Pràśhâńţ Řãj (50% atk), and - malloy - (50% atk) demonstrate minimal engagement. We need to initiate conversations with these chronic opt-outs to understand their intentions; those unwilling to participate should be removed to free up roster space.

WAR SIZE

With 20 genuinely reliable players and 3 moderately reliable players (snoop, T-Dub, Loading...) who haven't missed recent attacks, we have 23 committed members. To maximize reliability and fit war size rules, we recommend a 20-person war, focusing on our most consistent attackers. This ensures every slot is filled by a dependable player.

CUT LIST

To reach a 20-person war from 31 opted-in, 11 players need to be cut. Starting from the least reliable and those with recent missed attacks: Rico ll, ⚜Who Dat⚜, The Godfather, nirvana, PRO⚡️EMPEROR, LilWeezyAna, BigDaddyDyl, Anthony, MJ Belim. Additionally, Dr Halal (low 1.25 avg) and snoop (1.78 avg among moderates) should be considered to reach the target of 20, prioritizing overall war strength.

ACTION ITEM

Implement a strict "two missed attacks and you're out of the next war" policy for opted-in members to immediately address the pervasive issue of missed attacks and improve war reliability.